Note: This post originally appeared in January 2012 on www.berkeleyplaceblog.com. All comic book content is being gradually reprinted on this site.
THE TOP 10 COMIC BOOK CROSSOVERS
10. DC vs. Marvel. The 1996 battle royale crossover series. Each issue, a Marvel and DC hero would fight, with the outcome determined by reader voting. Very cool concept. In execution, it was just decent. But we did get to see Aquaman fight Namor, Flash race Quicksilver, Thor vs. Shazam…Even Elektra and Catwoman mixed it up.
9. Marvel Team-Up #14. Robert Kirkman relaunched the Spidey-meets-person-of-the-month title back in 2008, and the book was surprisingly good. I highly recommend it if you’re into fun, quirky superbooks. Plus, in issue #14, Spider-Man meets Invincible!
8. Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles #8. Wherein the “new jack” black and white indie animal team met the most important anthropomorphic indie hero of all time. Fun story.
7. Avengers/Squadron Sinister and Supreme issues. Well, not really. Long before any “official” crossover, The Avengers in issues #70, 85-86, and 147-48 met The Squadron Sinister (a.k.a. Squadron Supreme), a clear parallel to the JLA. It was pretty darn cool. These are actually my favorite kinds of crossovers. DC did this too, in the pages of Superman (in which he met The Kookie Quartet, Cobweb Kid, and Sub-Moron in The Inferior Five #10), but it wasn’t nearly as good because it wasn’t played straight. And if I’m mentioning this, then I should also throw in X-Men #107, in which Chris Claremont created the Imperial Guard who were clearly based on DC’s Legion of Super-Heroes (artist Dave Cockrum has just come to Marvel from DC, where he’d been drawing…you guessed it!). And then there was the time that Walt Simonson threw Kent into a few panels during his legendary Thor run. Pick up the Simonson Thor Omnibus if you haven’t already for an example of how great comics were in the 1980s.
6. Hulk vs. Superman. I’m putting up this one because it was written by Roger Stern and drawn by the always fantastic Steve Rude. It’s not a great story (but also not an awful one), but the art is probably the best from any crossover, ever.
5. Archie Meets The Punisher. Frank Castle tracks his prey into Riverdale, where he meets up with Archie’s crew at a school dance. Written by Batton Lash, and drawn by both John Buscema (on big Pun) and Stan Goldberg (on the Archies). Yes, it’s kitsch, but it’s wonderful. With cameos by Millie the Model, Josie and the Pussycats, Katy Keene, Sabrina The Teenage Witch, and a mention of Doc Strange. Note: Punisher has also met Eminem, if you’re looking for pure weirdness. But don’t look too hard for that one. It’s pretty awful.
4. Batman vs. Hulk. The second “oversize” crossover book, by Len Wein and Jose Luis Garcia-Lopez, wasn’t quite as good as the first, but the really cool thing about it was that although DC (predictably) threw Joker into the mix, on the Marvel side we had…Shaper of Worlds(!), an esoteric Hulk villain from 1972.
3. JLA/Avengers by the team of Kurt Busiek and George Perez. The “real” crossover, not like that silly one I put in above. I’m such a jerk, ruining this list with clutter. And yet, if I didn’t, I think I’d be hard pressed to come up with a sufficient number of comics that I could actually recommend. Crossovers usually suck, as I said above. As for this one: The story didn’t make a lot of sense (cosmic drivel) but the art? Every page is poster worthy. This was Perez at his prime.
2. The Battle of the Century: Superman vs. Spider-Man (1976). Bringing in all A-list talent: Gerry Conway, Ross Andru, Neal Adams, and John Romita, Sr., Marvel and DC started out with a great, all-ages story that didn’t bother to go into a big cosmic “how are we both here” kinda thing. Note: Do NOT confuse this with Marvel Treasury Edition #28: Superman and Spider-Man, in which the pair fought The Parasite and Dr. Doom, and met up with Hulk and Wonder Woman. That one is bloody awful, despite that it was written by Jim Shooter and Marv Wolfman with art by the great John Buscema.
1. X-Men/New Teen Titans. With writing by Chris Claremont and art by Walt Simonson, DC was wise to leave this one in the hands of Marvel staffers—it was phenomenal. The best Marvel/DC cross-over of all time, and still a great read.
What was the one where they “combined” DC and Marvel heroes? i seem to recall that one was decent.
Don’t make me start digging through my old long boxes.
“Amalgam.”
Although this is a fun read, you do know its very foundation is false. That “Bleeding Cool” article was quickly discovered to be a prank pulled on Rich by Diamond for stealing shite from their website. There is no upcoming Spidey/Bats crossover happening.
Lo siento, my friend.
I remember the 1996 “DC vs. Marvel” series. It was awfully convenient that fan voting or no it ended up in a “tie” which lead to the “Amalgam” short lived comics. The merger of DC’s “Flash” and Marvel’s “Ghost Rider” was a cool looking character, Superboy and Spiderman(?) not so much, but it was interesting…
Excellent items from you, man. I’ve keep in mind your stuff previous to and you are simply too wonderful. I really like what you have bought here, certainly like what you’re stating and the way in which you are saying it. You make it enjoyable and you still care for to keep it wise. I cant wait to learn much more from you. That is really a tremendous website.
I like reading an article that can make men and women
think. Also, many thanks for permitting me to comment!