Series: Captain America (1968-2012)

Stan Lee and Jack Kirby.  Grade: B+.  #100-109 (1968)
Stan Lee and Jim Steranko.  Grade: A.  #110-113 (1968-1969)
Stan Lee and John Romita, Sr.  Grade: B-. #114, 138-141 (1969, 1971)
Stan Lee and Gene Colan.  Grade: B.  #116-137 (1969-1971)
Gary Friedrich and John Romita, Sr. and Sal Buscema.  Grade: C+.  #142-148 (1971-1972)
Steve Englehart and (mostly) Sal Buscema.  Grade: A.  #153-167, 169-186 (1972-1975)
Jack Kirby.  Grade: C+.  #193-214 (1976-1977)
Roy Thomas and various.  Grade: C. #214-221 (1977-1978)
Roger Stern and John Byrne.  Grade: A+.  #247-255 (1980-1981) 
J.M. DeMatteis (starting with #261) and (mostly) Mike Zeck.  Grade: A-.  #259-302 (1981-1985)
Mark Gruenwald and various.  Grade: B+ (early issues); B- (later issues).  #307-443 (1985-1995)
Captain America Vol. 5 (picks up vol 1 numbering)
Ed Brubaker and (mostly) Steve Epting and Butch Guice.  Grade A+. #1-50, 600-19, 1-19, 620-628.  (2005-2012) 

Note: Series returned for a few issues in 2018 as part of the Legacy event.